One Story. Eight Audiences. Very Different Reactions.

One of the biggest mistakes leaders, institutions, and communicators make is assuming “the public” is a single audience.

It isn’t.

People consume media differently based on time, trust, temperament, identity, and emotional bandwidth. That difference shapes what they believe, how fast they believe it, and whether they’ll ever reconsider it.

If you don’t understand how someone consumes information, you’ll misread why they react the way they do.

Below are the most common types of media consumers shaping today’s public discourse—and why each requires a different communication approach.

1. The Headline Scanner

Informed enough to talk. Not informed enough to evaluate.

How they consume

• Headlines

• Push notifications

• Social captions

• Group chats

What drives them

• Speed

• Emotional clarity

• Social relevance

Strength

• Quickly aware of breaking issuesRisk

• High susceptibility to misinformation

• Strong opinions with thin context

RAE insight:If your message doesn’t survive the headline alone, it won’t survive this audience.

2. The Algorithm-Fed Consumer

Reality shaped by what shows up next.

How they consume

• TikTok

• Instagram Reels

• X threads

• YouTube clips

What drives them

• Repetition

• Emotion

• Familiar faces

Strength

• Highly engaged

• Strong recall of narrativesRisk

• Confuses popularity with truth

• Mistakes confidence for competence

RAE insight:This audience doesn’t ask “Is it true?”They ask “Does this feel right—and does everyone else agree?”

3. The Trust-Based Consumer

Believes the messenger more than the message.

How they consume

• Favorite anchors

• Trusted influencers

• Community leaders

• Faith or cultural figures

What drives them

• Familiarity

• Shared values

• Identity alignment

Strength

• Loyal and consistentRisk

• Rarely cross-checks

• Resistant to contradictory evidence

RAE insight:Trust transfer matters more here than data.

4. The Confirmation Seeker

Consuming to validate, not to learn.

How they consume

• Opinion shows

• Ideological newsletters

• Comment sections

What drives them

• Identity protection

• Moral certainty

• Opposition to “the other side”

Strength

• Highly motivatedRisk

• Immune to nuance

• Treats disagreement as attack

RAE insight:Facts don’t fail here—identity blocks them.

5. The Deep-Dive Evaluator

Small in number. Big in influence.

How they consume

• Long-form articles

• Reports

• Podcasts

• Source documents

What drives them

• Understanding

• Accuracy

• Context

Strength

• Informed opinions

• High credibilityRisk

• Slow to react

• Easily drowned out by louder voices

RAE insight:This group doesn’t need persuasion—they need access.

6. The Emotionally Exhausted Consumer

Knows something is wrong. Too tired to engage.

How they consume

• Skims occasionally

• Avoids breaking news

• Relies on summaries

What drives them

• Cognitive overload

• Crisis fatigue

• Distrust

Strength

• Less reactiveRisk

• Disengagement

• Lower standards for clarity

RAE insight:Clarity, not volume, is what brings them back.

7. The Community Interpreter

Filters information through lived experience.

How they consume

• Local radio

• Community Facebook groups

• Neighborhood conversations

• Word of mouth

What drives them

• Practical impact

• Relevance

• Trust proximity

Strength

• Grounded perspectiveRisk

• Limited access to broader context

RAE insight:If it doesn’t touch daily life, it won’t land.

8. The Performative Consumer

Consuming to signal identity.

How they consume

• Viral content

• Shareable graphics

• Hot takes

What drives them

• Visibility

• Belonging

• Social approval

Strength

• Amplifies messages quicklyRisk

• Spreads oversimplified narratives

RAE insight:This group amplifies emotion—not accuracy.

Why This Matters

When institutions fail to segment audiences:

• Messages get misunderstood

• Trust erodes

• Silence fills with speculation

• Extremes dominate the conversation

Most public confusion isn’t caused by bad intentions.It’s caused by one-size-fits-all communication in a fragmented media world.

The RAE Reality Check

Effective communication today requires:

• Different formats for different consumers

• Clear hierarchy of information

• Repetition without distortion

• Honesty about limits and trade-offs

You don’t need to convince everyone.You need to be understood accurately by the right audiences.

The Bottom Line

People don’t just consume media differently.They interpret reality differently based on how they consume it.

If leaders want better public discourse, the answer isn’t louder messaging—it’s smarter segmentation.

RAE takeaway:Understanding media consumers isn’t marketing.It’s modern literacy.

If you want, I can:

• Turn this into a RAE framework graphic

• Add a Memphis-specific media ecosystem layer

• Create a training module for public officials

• Or condense this into a one-page briefing

Just tell me how you want to use it.

ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.

A vibrant outdoor market showcasing various products and engaging customers.

Types of CTAs to Consider

Different goals require different types of CTAs. Here are some common types to consider:

1. Lead Generation CTAs

These CTAs are designed to capture user information, such as email addresses. Examples include:

• "Download Our Free E-book"

• "Subscribe for Weekly Tips"

  
  

2. Sales CTAs

Sales CTAs encourage users to make a purchase. Examples include:

• "Buy Now and Save 20%"

• "Add to Cart"

  
  

3. Social Sharing CTAs

Encouraging users to share your content can expand your reach. Examples include:

• "Share This on Facebook"

• "Tweet This Article"

  
  

4. Event Registration CTAs

If you're hosting an event, use CTAs to drive registrations. Examples include:

• "Register for Our Webinar"

• "Reserve Your Spot Today"

  
  

5. Content Engagement CTAs

These CTAs encourage users to engage with your content further. Examples include:

• "Read More Articles Like This"

• "Watch Our Latest Video"

  
  

Crafting Your CTA Copy

The wording of your CTA is crucial. Here are some tips for writing compelling CTA copy:

Use Action-Oriented Language

Start with strong verbs that encourage action. Words like "Get," "Join," "Discover," and "Start" create a sense of movement.

Keep It Short

Aim for brevity. A concise CTA is easier to understand and remember. Ideally, keep it under five words.

Personalize When Possible

Personalization can increase engagement. Use language that speaks directly to your audience, such as "Join Our Community of Creatives."

Test Different Phrasings

Experiment with different phrases to see what resonates best with your audience. A simple change in wording can lead to significant differences in conversion rates.

Placement of CTAs

Where you place your CTAs can impact their effectiveness. Here are some strategic locations to consider:

Above the Fold

Placing a CTA above the fold ensures that it’s one of the first things users see when they land on your page. This is particularly effective for lead generation and sales CTAs.

End of Blog Posts

After providing valuable content, a CTA at the end of a blog post can encourage readers to take the next step, such as subscribing or downloading a resource.

In the Sidebar

A persistent sidebar CTA can keep your offer visible as users scroll through your content.

In Pop-ups

While pop-ups can be intrusive, when used sparingly and with the right timing, they can effectively capture attention and drive conversions.

Analyzing CTA Performance

To ensure your CTAs are effective, regularly analyze their performance. Here are some metrics to consider:

Click-Through Rate (CTR)

This metric measures how many users clicked on your CTA compared to how many saw it. A higher CTR indicates that your CTA is compelling.

Conversion Rate

Ultimately, the goal is to convert visitors into customers. Track how many users complete the desired action after clicking your CTA.

A/B Testing Results

If you’ve conducted A/B tests, analyze the results to determine which version of your CTA performed better and why.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even seasoned marketers can make mistakes with CTAs. Here are some common pitfalls to avoid:

Being Vague

Avoid vague language that doesn’t clearly communicate the action you want users to take. Instead of "Click Here," use specific phrases like "Download Your Free Guide."

Overloading with CTAs

Too many CTAs can overwhelm users. Focus on one primary CTA per page to guide users effectively.

Ignoring Mobile Users

Ensure your CTAs are optimized for mobile devices. A significant portion of web traffic comes from mobile users, so make sure your CTAs are easy to click on smaller screens.

Failing to Test

Never assume that your first version of a CTA is the best. Regular testing and optimization are key to improving performance.

Conclusion

A powerful call-to-action is essential for boosting conversions and guiding users toward taking the desired action. By focusing on clarity, urgency, visibility, and value, you can create CTAs that resonate with your audience. Remember to analyze performance and continuously optimize your CTAs for the best results.

Now, take a moment to review your current CTAs. Are they clear, compelling, and strategically placed? If not, it’s time to make some changes. Start crafting CTAs that not only attract attention but also drive action. Your conversion rates will thank you.